Home  

EC issues ultimatum to Romania: stop child exports

EC issues ultimatum to Romania: stop child exports

Adrian Nastase: under pressure to control child traffiking 

The European Commission has warned Romania to halt the export of children for adoption or face a bar on EU membership and the severance of aid funds.

The commission wrote to Adrian Nastase, the prime minister, warning that his government's conduct failed to meet the "political criteria" on human rights required for EU accession. Romania is hoping to join in 2007.

The unprecedented letter, signed by Gunther Verheugen, the enlargement commissioner, not only threatened to cut off aid but also referred to the need for a "recovery of funds" already spent unless Bucharest can account for its actions.

Officials say £42 million of aid is at risk.

The dispute comes after Italian reports that Romania had sent 105 children to Italy on dubious pretexts, confirming suspicions in Brussels that the Nastase government is turning a blind eye to racketeering by adoption agencies and corrupt officials.

Romania imposed a moratorium on adoptions in 2001 at the request of Lady Nicholson, a Liberal-Democrat MEP and the European Parliament's "rapporteur" on Romania. She said organised crime was exploiting reports about the country's orphanages as a "cover" for a much wider child-abuse industry.

More than 30,000 children were shipped out for adoption over 10 years, generating hundreds of millions of pounds for agencies and middle men. Each child fetched £20,000 to £35,000.

Few were actually orphans and some were stolen babies. Last month it was disclosed that a maternity hospital at Ploiesti had been tricking mothers by pretending their premature babies died at birth.

The infants were in fact "fattened" in a pre-natal wing for six months before being exported. It is claimed that 23 babies were smuggled out by the hospital last year alone.

In other cases, vulnerable young girls were pressured into giving up their babies for as little as £300 cash.

Lady Nicholson said little had changed since the moratorium was imposed. "It is a well-oiled machine that seems to rest on a partnership between the adoption agencies and corrupt officials, from top to bottom of the administration. There are wonderful people making huge efforts to stop it but they are not winning.

"The courts appear to be corrupt. One judge rubber-stamped 92 cases in a single morning. There are no files. Children are just a number in a computer. The agencies get a court order and grab the child. It's kidnapping.

"Some are girls and boys approaching puberty. They are sent off against their will to an unknown future. I shudder to think of their fate. You see advertisements on the internet for pre-pubescent virgins with a $30,000 price tag."

Outraged Euro-MPs are demanding that Romania's request to join the EU be put on ice. A draft resolution by the European Parliament calls for "root-and-branch reform of the justice system" before renewing accession talks.

According to official figures, 1,000 Romanian children have been adopted abroad over the last two years but the real number could be much higher.

Mr Nastase said they were "pipeline cases" dating from commitments back to 2001, claiming that foreign parents were already living with the children in Romania.

But Mr Verheugen disputed the claim, noting that most were taken from foster homes or "other suitable care situations" in Romania.

An EU official said: "They were happily settled. Romania is a poor country and so these families don't have swimming pools in the yard but foster care is no worse than in any other country."

While most adoptive parents in the EU and America offer loving homes, the Commission said lack of tracking data made it impossible to know where children ended up.

"There is a very big risk that a number fall into the hands of paedophile networks. I didn't believe it for a long time but all the evidence points that way," said an official.

Romanian officials say they are caught in a tug-of-war between two camps. While one part of the EU demands an adoption ban, Italy, Spain, and France want laxer rules to meet their collapsing fertility rates.

Adrian Nastase: under pressure to control child traffiking By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard in Brussels 12:01AM GMT 04 Feb 2004

The European Commission has warned Romania to halt the export of children for adoption or face a bar on EU membership and the severance of aid funds.

The commission wrote to Adrian Nastase, the prime minister, warning that his government's conduct failed to meet the "political criteria" on human rights required for EU accession. Romania is hoping to join in 2007.

Interview Marijke Zaalberg

Naar School in Haïti

Februari 2004: De stichting biedt inmiddels aan heel veel kinderen onderwijs. Graag verwijs ik hiervoor naar haar eigen site.

Gert Hardeman

Oorspronkelijke tekst:

Elk kind heeft recht op voeding, kleding, onderdak en onderwijs. Dit recht wordt werkelijkheid voor de kinderen "van" de Stichting Naar School in Haïti. De stichting doet meer dan haar naam aangeeft, maar daarmee begint het wel: het volgen van onderwijs is het begin van het einde van armoede.

birthparent search in Romania

Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes

#1

02-19-2004, 11:24 AM

mama4kidz

Junior Member

CoE: Information on the use of your contributions and donations: help for abandoned children in Romania

(February 2004) Information on the use of your contributions and donations: help for abandoned children in Romania

(French only)

Grâce à vos contributions et dons réguliers, l’Association des agents du Conseil de l’Europe "Entraide-Solidarités" participe depuis plusieurs années aux efforts menés en Roumanie pour sortir les enfants abandonnés, parfois handicapés, des institutions inhumaines ou tout le moins pour rénover ou reconstruire ces institutions.

En 2003, l’association a soutenu l’action de SERA et M. François de Combret (SERA) nous écrit :

"... Le petit garçon qui a dessiné ce bonhomme de neige s'appelle Nelu ; il a 9 ans. Abandonné à la naissance, il a vécu ses premières années dans le sinistre "mouroir" de Ungureni (Roumanie). Grâce à votre générosité et à celle d'autres donateurs de SERA, il est sorti de cet enfer et il se trouve maintenant dans un orphelinat spécialement aménagé pour lui et 41 autres petits rescapés de Ungureni. Dans ce nouvel orphelinat, Nelu a accompli de grands progrès, comme le montre le joli dessin ci-joint.

State seizes books of Holt foster-parent organization

State seizes books of Holt foster-parent organization

State seizes books of Holt foster-parent organization

Monday, January 26, 2004

By The Associated Press

HOLT -- State authorities are investigating the possible embezzlement

An independent voice for ethical adoption

UNICEF has released an official position statement on intercountry adoption, which clarifies the often controversial Article 21 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

The ambiguity of Article 21 has lead some to interpret the Article as supportive of long term institutionalization over intercountry adoption--a position that at times seemed to be an official stance of UNICEF.

The Statement, released on 01/15/04, acknowledges that institutionalization should be a short term measure, and that intercountry adoption should be an option when a permanent family cannot be found for the child in his or her country of birth.

The statement also acknowledges the problems that often occur in adoption, and encourages the use of the Hague Convention as one solution to these problems.

Ethica strongly believes that reform of the intercountry adoption process is necessary in many countries of origin and in receiving countries. On the other hand, it must be acknowledged that rapid and unplanned changes often result in moratoria and the rapid decline of protective child welfare services in many countries, often making children even more vulnerable to human rights abuses. In light of this, Ethica strongly supports the gradual implementation of changes which address both short and long term goals for establishing appropriate child welfare policies.

U.S. Adoption Agent Blasts Armenian Orphan Placement Plan

in English

U.S. Adoption Agent Blasts Armenian Orphan Placement Plan

19.01.2004
By Emil Danielyan
A U.S. middleman specializing in arranging adoptions of Armenian children has slammed as “ridiculous” the Armenian government’s plans to encourage local families to host and raise the orphans until they come of age.

The scheme, announced last week, is part of the government’s stated efforts to reduce the number of such children adopted by foreign nationals each year. Officials said they have already secured donor funding for the unprecedented scheme.

Writing in an Internet discussion group, Robin Sizemore of the U.S.-based Carolina Adoption Services (CAS), claims that orphans placed in a caretaker family would not necessarily be happier and might even be abused by caretaker parents.

“I am worried sick to think that a child would leave the institution and be placed in an unsuspecting and uneducated family,” Sizemore said in a message posted on the online forum Sunday. “Not only for the family, but most of all for the child that will never get the therapy needed and most likely become a victim of abuse and perhaps run away and become a child of the street.”

The planned arrangement, which requires corresponding amendments to Armenia’s laws on children’s rights and education, does not amount to a formal adoption of children. Caretaker families will simply be required to bring up orphans as their own children in return for a monthly financial compensation from the state. According to Deputy Minister of Labor and Social Affairs Ashot Yesayan, the government will pay at least 50,000 drams ($90) per child for food expenses alone.

Yesayan assured reporters last Thursday that families willing to take in children from state-run orphanages will undergo close scrutiny based on a dozen selection criteria to be set by his ministry. Those include the size of their income, the state of their “physical and mental health” as well as the opinion of their neighbors and colleagues, he said.

But Sizemore, who is in charge of CAS activities in Armenia and neighboring Georgia, warned: “One should not romance the idea that just a loving stable home will remedy any issue. This sets the child up for abuse in the foster home as the parents will not have the education, training, support or resources to deal with these issues.”

CAS is one of several private U.S. adoption agencies operating in Armenia either directly or through local agents familiar with a long list of Armenian officials in a position to affect the process. Other local facilitators work directly with adoptive parents in the U.S. and Europe.

There has been a steady increase in foreign adoptions in the country in recent years. According to official figures, at least 76 Armenian children were adopted by foreigners, most of them Americans of Armenian extraction, last year.

It is not known how many of them were taken abroad through CAS and other U.S. agencies. They typically charge their clients between $9,000 and $13,000 per child -- a suspiciously high figure given the much lower cost of official paperwork inside Armenia. An RFE/RL report suggested last year that a large part of the money is spent on bribes to local government officials.

The report led Social Affairs Minister Aghvan Vartanian, who took over shortly before its publication in June, to ask prosecutors to launch an official inquiry. Vartanian was also the main initiator of changes in the adoption rules approved by the Armenian government last month. They are primarily aimed at facilitating domestic adoptions.

Sources told RFE/RL that Vartanian’s ministry was pushing for much tougher rules that would exclude the middlemen from the process and subject foreign adoptive parents to stricter scrutiny. They said the proposals were not accepted by the cabinet of Prime Minister Andranik Markarian, which has the final say on every single foreign adoption in Armenia.

As things stand now, the foreigners face few requirements except having a minimum annual income of $24,000 each. They are not even personally interviewed by a government commission overseeing the process.

Helping children find their way home

Helping children find their way home

Activist works for change in Albania

By Paul Massari, Globe Correspondent | January 18, 2004

Fisher Avenue in Newton Highlands has been seeing less and less of longtime resident Harriet Epstein.

Over the past five years, Epstein has taught public health in Ghana and helped survivors of Kosovo atrocities get counseling. Now she is in Albania trying to transform the lives of the nation's abandoned children, a challenge she describes as the greatest of her 35-year career.

Cantwell visiting EU Delegation: ica before institutions (preparing Unicef position) (DRAFT BOOK)

Exact date is in book Romania for Export

CANTWELL JAN 2004

Towards the end of January, in the middle of the Nastase -Berlusconi crises, I receive

in my office Nigel Cantwell, whom Unicef considered their expert in adoptions. I had

met Nigel before and I had read his reports about intercountry adoptions in Romania.

Geneticist's sentence reduced in adoption ruling

After an appeal the Superior Court of Budapest has reduced the sentence given to the prominent Hungarian geneticist Endre Czeizel, who was found guilty in a lower court last year on four counts of being an accessory in a transatlantic infant adoption scheme, in violation of Hungary's Family Act (BMJ 2002;325:238 3 August). On 18 December the Superior Court dismissed three of the charges against Dr Czeizel, reduced the fourth to a violation of Hungary's adoption code, and fined him 200 000 forints (£540; $950; €760). Three of eight codefendants who were found guilty at the earlier trial also had their sentences reduced or dismissed. A July 2002 trial in Budapest Metropolitan Court culminated in Dr Czeizel being sentenced to 18 months in prison, suspended for two years. Six codefendants were given suspended sentences of one to three years, on jail terms ranging from three months to two years, and two were given reprimands. Dr Czeizel was originally accused of encouraging pregnant women—most of them impoverished and from the countryside—to give up their newborn babies for adoption in the United States in exchange for a trip to that country, where they would enjoy a few weeks of high quality accommodation, give birth, and receive cash for relinquishing their infants. Dr Czeizel's co-conspirator, prosecutors said, was Marianna Gáti, a Hungarian with American citizenship currently living in the United States. Prosecutors alleged that Ms Gáti, together with social workers and lawyers, set up an organisation to arrange adoptions of Hungarian babies for American couples, charging them tens of thousands of dollars for her services. Dr Czeizel steadfastly denied receiving any money for arranging adoptions. However, during the lower court's sentencing hearing the judge read a letter from Ms Gáti to Dr Czeizel's personal secretary saying, "$500 is yours and $1000 to Dr C." In January Ms Gáti pleaded guilty in a Californian court to one count of the federal offence of wire fraud (using interstate communication facilities to carry out a scheme to defraud), in connection with allegedly arranging the sale of as many as 30 Hungarian infants, some for as much as $80 000.

.