A 51-year-old woman from the Enz district has been sentenced to prison for defamation of Pforzheim Member of the Bundestag Gunther Krichbaum and his wife Dr. Oana Krichbaum. By decision of November 15, 2023, the 1st Criminal Senate of the Karlsruhe Higher Regional Court dismissed as unfounded the defendant's appeal against a judgment of the Pforzheim Criminal Division of the Karlsruhe Regional Court dated March 8, 2023. This judgment sentenced the defendant to a total of seven months' imprisonment, one month of which is considered served due to procedural delays contrary to the rule of law.
According to the findings of the Regional Court, the defendant had alleged in numerous Facebook posts and in emails to various recipients, including newspaper editorial staff and members of state and federal parliaments, that Dr. Oana Krichbaum had been involved in illegal child trafficking in Romania and that Gunther Krichbaum had attempted to cover this up by exploiting his political office. After initially pursuing civil action against the defendant, the Krichbaum couple filed a criminal complaint on April 23, 2018, regarding three Facebook posts published by the defendant on February 13, February 26, and March 26, 2018, all of which referred to Dr. Oana Krichbaum and, in two cases, to Gunter Krichbaum. The defendant continued to make similar defamatory allegations, even in her final statement at the appeal hearing before the Regional Court. In its judgment, the Regional Court also found that the defendants’ allegations were neither demonstrably true nor covered by freedom of expression or other legitimate interests of the defendants.
The Karlsruhe Regional Court sentenced the defendant to six months' imprisonment each for the three offenses mentioned in 2018, which are the sole subject of these proceedings, and combined these individual sentences into a total prison sentence of seven months. The Regional Court declared one month of this sentence to have already been served due to a procedural delay that occurred during the appeal proceedings, which violated the rule of law. The Regional Court did not suspend the execution of the total prison sentence because it did not consider the defendant to have a positive criminal prognosis, as neither the civil proceedings nor the previous criminal proceedings had deterred her from continuing to make defamatory allegations about the Krichbaum couple.
In the appeal proceedings, the First Criminal Senate of the Higher Regional Court had to examine both the content of the Regional Court's written reasons for the judgment and – to the extent challenged by the defendants' defense – the proceedings before the Regional Court for legal errors that may have affected the decision. However, the Senate did not identify any such legal errors on which the Regional Court's judgment was based. In particular, it did not consider the offenses to be time-barred and did not object to the defense's rejection of applications for auxiliary evidence. The fact that a witness's email was read out at the main hearing instead of her being questioned clearly had no effect on the content of the Regional Court's judgment. The Regional Court correctly considered the defendants' fundamental right to freedom of expression. The Regional Court's sentencing – including the failure to grant a suspended sentence – is also not objectionable under the law of appeal.
No further appeal is available. The Karlsruhe Regional Court's ruling is now final.